More answers like this
Claude Sonnet 5Sep 25, 2026anthropic/claude-sonnet-5-20260630

Were a majority of the Gazan journalists killed since October 7th, 2023 linked to terrorist organizations?

Short answer: This is a contested claim, not an established fact.

There are competing analyses with very different conclusions:

The "majority linked to terror" claim comes from a study by an Israeli think tank, the Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center. That study examined the identities of 266 individuals identified as journalists or media workers killed in Gaza between October 7, 2023, and November 30, 2025, and concluded at least 157 of them—roughly 60 percent—were members of terror groups or clearly affiliated with them. The researchers said they based this on the argument that under international law, anyone participating in fighting—even gathering intelligence, as journalistic reports sometimes do—becomes a legitimate target, and that terror groups deliberately exploit journalistic status.

The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), the leading international press-freedom watchdog, has documented far higher casualty figures and does not find that a majority were combatants. CPJ explicitly states its methodology removes names from its database if subsequent evidence shows individuals were not journalists or media workers, were not active in those capacities at the time of their deaths, or were directly participating in hostilities.

CPJ has made some corrections after review, but nowhere near the scale the Israeli think-tank study claims. In September 2026, CPJ announced that 19 Palestinians it had previously identified as journalists or media workers were actually militants or participants in combat, and it removed another three Palestinians from its list because their role as journalists could not be established. In total, since the Oct. 7 attack, CPJ has removed a total of 27 people from its list of slain journalists after finding that they participated in combat or belonged to a militant group. After that review, CPJ says Israeli forces have killed 191 Palestinian journalists and media workers since the start of the war in Gaza.

27 removals out of roughly 200+ documented deaths is nowhere near a majority — it's about 12-13%.

Key points of dispute:

1.Definition of "linked to": The Israeli study counts anyone "affiliated with" Hamas-run or Islamic-Jihad-linked outlets as tied to terror groups, since the terrorist organizations, headed by Hamas, operate many affiliated media outlets in the Strip which spread their propaganda and disinformation. Critics would note that in Gaza, most local media is government-run (by the Hamas-led administration), so "affiliation" with a Hamas-run outlet is a much lower bar than being an actual combatant or fighter.
2.Evidence basis: The Israeli institute says its findings relied on Arabic-language sources, social media profiles, and captured Hamas documents, including a roster from Hamas' Gaza Brigade that confirmed eight individuals previously listed as unidentified journalists were actually Hamas members. This kind of evidence (captured documents attributed to Israeli intelligence) is difficult for outside parties to independently verify.
3.Individual case controversy: The most prominent example, Al Jazeera correspondent Anas Al-Sharif, illustrates the dispute directly — the IDF asserted Anas Al-Sharif "posed as an Al Jazeera journalist" and "was the head of a Hamas terrorist cell and advanced rocket attacks on Israeli civilians and IDF troops." Al Jazeera and press-freedom groups disputed this characterization.
4.CPJ's overall assessment remains that the deliberate targeting and killing of a journalist by any military, who are required to protect civilians under international law, constitutes a war crime, and it maintains that Israel is responsible for the majority of press deaths in this war, calling it unparalleled disregard for the lives of journalists, making this war the deadliest on record for journalists since CPJ began collecting data in 1992.

Bottom line

The "majority were linked to terrorism" figure traces to a single Israeli intelligence-linked think tank study using a broad definition of "affiliation" (including working for Hamas-run media outlets) and evidence that is largely unverifiable by independent parties. The primary international journalist-tracking organization (CPJ), after its own internal review, found that only a small fraction (roughly 12-13%) of those it had listed were combatants or militants — not a majority. So the claim is disputed and depends heavily on which definition of "linked to terrorism" and which source's methodology you accept.

Citations (12)

  1. 1timesofisrael.comNews and mediaquality 0.82
    Majority of journalists killed in Gaza linked to terror organizations, study says | The Times of Israel

    Source excerpt: “The study (Hebrew link), published Thursday, examined the identities of 266 individuals identified as journalists or media workers killed in Gaza betw...”

  2. 2yahoo.comNews and mediaquality 0.69
    Some 60% of journalists killed in Gaza were part of terrorist organizations

    Source excerpt: “Therefore, from the point of view of international law, it is forbidden to intentionally harm someone who is not participating in the fighting, but as...”

  3. 3cpj.orgNonprofits and think tanks
    Journalist casualties in the Israel-Gaza war - Committee to Protect Journalists

    Source excerpt: “... CPJ removes names from its database if subsequent evidence shows individuals were not journalists or media workers, were not active in those capac...”

  4. 4washingtontimes.comNews and mediaquality 0.35
    Rights group says some people it classified as journalists killed in Gaza were militants

    Source excerpt: “The Committee to Protect Journalists said Thursday that 19 Palestinians killed by Israeli fire who it had previously identified as journalists or medi...”

  5. 5washingtontimes.comNews and mediaquality 0.35
    Rights group says some people it classified as journalists killed in Gaza were militants

    Source excerpt: “It removed another three Palestinians from its list because their role as journalists could not be established. ”

  6. 6washingtontimes.comNews and mediaquality 0.35
    Rights group says some people it classified as journalists killed in Gaza were militants

    Source excerpt: “Since the Oct. 7 attack, CPJ has removed a total of 27 people from its list of slain journalists after finding that they participated in combat or bel...”

  7. 7washingtontimes.comNews and mediaquality 0.35
    Rights group says some people it classified as journalists killed in Gaza were militants

    Source excerpt: “After a review of its tally, it says Israeli forces have killed 191 Palestinian journalists and media workers since the start of the war in Gaza. ”

  8. 8terrorism-info.org.ilNonprofits and think tanks
    About 60% of the Gazans Classified as "Journalists" and Other Media Personnel Killed in the Gaza Strip War Belonged to Hamas and Other Terrorist Organizations - The Amit Terrorism and Intelligence Research Institute

    Source excerpt: “The terrorist organizations, headed by Hamas, operate many affiliated media outlets in the Strip which spread their propaganda and disinformation; Dur...”

  9. 9jpost.comNews and mediaquality 0.81
    Gaza journalist deaths linked to Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, study finds | The Jerusalem Post

    Source excerpt: “Mofaz said the study relied on Arabic-language sources, social media profiles, and captured Hamas documents. A roster from Hamas’ Gaza Brigade confirm...”

  10. 10tribuneindia.comNot yet classified
    5 journalists killed in idf attack on gaza tent israel alleges hamas link

    Source excerpt: “"STRUCK: Hamas terrorist Anas Al-Sharif, who posed as an Al Jazeera journalist. Al-Sharif was the head of a Hamas terrorist cell and advanced rocket a...”

  11. 11cpj.orgNonprofits and think tanks
    Record 129 press members killed in 2025; Israel responsible for 2/3 of deaths - Committee to Protect Journalists

    Source excerpt: “The deliberate targeting and killing of a journalist by any military, who are required to protect civilians under international law, constitutes a war...”

  12. 12cpj.orgNonprofits and think tanks
    Journalist casualties in the Israel-Gaza war - Committee to Protect Journalists

    Source excerpt: “Israel’s disregard for the lives of journalists — and for the international laws designed to protect them — is unparalleled. Israel has now killed mor...”