More answers like this
Claude Sonnet 5Sep 19, 2026anthropic/claude-sonnet-5-20260630

Is Donald Trump improving the US government?

This is a subjective question that depends heavily on political perspective and which criteria you use to judge "improvement." Rather than offering my own opinion, let me search for how different analysts and sources are currently assessing his administration's impact.Whether Trump is "improving" the US government depends entirely on your criteria and political perspective—there's no neutral, objective answer, but here's what different sources say:

Public opinion has soured considerably. When Trump began his second term, his approval rating was 47%, and throughout 2025 to 2026, it has steadily declined to an average of 37 to 39%. As of mid-2026, Trump's job approval sat at 34%, lower than most recent presidents at comparable points, with a partisan gap of 78 percentage points. Some of this decline appears tied to economic concerns—the approval decline tracks closely with economic anxiety, particularly tariff-driven price increases that consumers began feeling in early 2026.

The administration's own claims of success: The White House touts major accomplishments. In less than two years, the administration claims to have driven "the most consequential stretch of governing in modern American history," sealing the border, driving violent crime to historic lows, unleashing American energy, cutting taxes, and focusing on merit-based governance. On government efficiency specifically, the White House states efforts have saved an estimated $215 billion, equivalent to $1,335 per U.S. taxpayer, and deregulation is projected to save the economy $1.5 trillion in FY2026 alone.

Independent watchdog groups disagree sharply. The nonpartisan Partnership for Public Service reached the opposite conclusion. Their first-anniversary report on federal workforce reductions concluded they have decreased the effectiveness of government services, not achieved stated efficiency goals, and were conducted with minimal transparency. Notably, they point out the administration failed to improve government efficiency despite that being the stated motivation, since government spending actually increased between fiscal 2024 and 2025. They also flagged redundancy in new initiatives—criticizing the "Tech Force" program as duplicative of the U.S. Digital Service (which Trump transformed into DOGE) and 18F, a group the administration had already eliminated.

Bottom line: This is a genuinely contested question with legitimate disagreement between:

•Supporters/the administration point to border security, crime reduction, deregulation, and cost savings as evidence of a more efficient, effective government.
•Critics/watchdog groups argue the workforce cuts and reorganization actually reduced government effectiveness while failing to deliver promised savings, and note declining public trust as reflected in approval polling.

If you want, I can dig deeper into a specific area (e.g., economy, immigration, DOGE cost-cutting claims, or civil service impacts) where I can find more detailed data to help you form your own judgment.

Citations (9)

  1. 1wikipedia.orgEncyclopedias and referencequality 0.83
    Opinion polling on the second Trump presidency

    Source excerpt: “At the time when Donald Trump began his second term, his approval rating was 47%, [[3]](./Opinion_polling_on_the_second_Trump_presidency#cite_note-3) ...”

  2. 2pewresearch.orgNonprofits and think tanks
    Trump’s job approval rating is low by historical standards | Pew Research Center

    Source excerpt: “Trump's job approval sits at 34%, lower than most recent presidents at comparable points, with a partisan gap of 78 percentage points. ”

  3. 3uspollingdata.comData and tools
    Trump Approval Rating 2026 — Monthly Tracker & Historical Comparison

    Source excerpt: “Trump's approval decline from 47% at inauguration to 38.1% by May 2026 tracks almost perfectly with economic anxiety indicators — particularly the tar...”

  4. 4whitehouse.govGovernment
    President Trump Delivers Historic Results for the American People in Under Two Years – The White House

    Source excerpt: “In less than two years, President Donald J. Trump has driven the most consequential stretch of governing in modern American history. He inherited a di...”

  5. 5whitehouse.govGovernment
    Reform Government (DOGE) – The White House

    Source excerpt: “September 18, 2026 Read more: Enhancing ... Visa Program · Government efficiency efforts have saved an estimated $215 billion, equivalent to $1,335 pe...”

  6. 6whitehouse.govGovernment
    President Trump Delivers Historic Results for the American People in Under Two Years – The White House

    Source excerpt: “President Trump’s government-wide deregulatory mandate is projected to save the U.S. economy $1.5 trillion in FY2026 alone. ”

  7. 7govexec.comNews and mediaquality 0.87
    ‘Harder days ahead in 2026’: Good government group predicts increased political interference in the civil service in Trump’s second year - Government Executive

    Source excerpt: “Experimental to operational: How Daston Corporation and Google Public Sector deliver mission-driven AI ... On the first anniversary of President Don...”

  8. 8govexec.comNews and mediaquality 0.87
    ‘Harder days ahead in 2026’: Good government group predicts increased political interference in the civil service in Trump’s second year - Government Executive

    Source excerpt: “The Partnership contended that the Trump administration also has failed to improve government efficiency, even though that was the stated motivation b...”

  9. 9govexec.comNews and mediaquality 0.87
    ‘Harder days ahead in 2026’: Good government group predicts increased political interference in the civil service in Trump’s second year - Government Executive

    Source excerpt: “The report also criticized the Tech Force, a new initiative to recruit technologists for short-term stints in agencies. The Partnership argued that ...”