What are the threats of today's political climate in the US?
Today's U.S. political climate carries several emerging threats — I'll gather current reporting to map what's driving them.
In today's U.S. political climate, scholars, government agencies and research organizations point to several converging threats:
1. Extreme and Toxic Polarization
Political polarization in the United States is real and has been increasing over time. Research describes a 'tipping point' where once polarization reaches a critical point, dynamics cannot be reversed even in response to a common threat.
The effect is a condition where there is no evidence that campaigns will reduce partisan polarization that has blocked progress on vital national problems, and research now finds polarization may have broader impact hindering democracies' capacity to address climate change.
A Cornell analysis identifies four threats that endanger democracy – political polarization; conflict over who belongs as a full member of the political community; rising economic inequality; and the concentration of power in the nation's top leader — that have converged for the first time in American history.
2. Rise in Political Violence and Extremism
The rise both of threats and actual violence shows the dangerous levels of polarization, extremism, and radicalization that we face in America today. In the current period, people see opponents as enemies and many do not trust the motives or actions of opposition leaders.
The Department of Homeland Security warns that in the coming months, we expect the threat environment to become more dynamic as several high-profile events could be exploited to justify acts of violence, with actors mobilized due to factors such as personal grievances and adherence to violent extremist ideologies, including racially or ethnically motivated or anti-government/anti-authority violent extremism.
3. Erosion of Trust and Truth Decay
Rand Corporation defines the current discourse as "Truth Decay," defined as increasing disagreement about facts, a blurring of the line between opinion and fact, an increase in the relative volume of opinion compared with fact, and lowered trust in formerly respected sources.
Drivers include cognitive bias, changes in the information system including social media and the 24-hour news cycle, competing demands on education, and polarization.
Consequences include:
4. Threats to Democratic Institutions and Elections
Taken together, analysts describe a feedback loop: polarization and changes in the information ecosystem drive Truth Decay and distrust, which fuels alienation and willingness to accept political violence, which in turn makes governing, elections, and addressing long-term problems like inequality and climate change more difficult.
Citations (3)
- Op-Ed: Four deadly threats to American democracy are raging all at once | Department of Government
Backs: “The effect is a condition where there is no evidence that campaigns will reduce partisan polarization that has blocked progress on vital national problems, and research now finds polarization may have broader impact hindering democracies' capacity to address climate change. A Cornell analysis identifies four threats…”
- We need to take political violence seriously | Brookings
Backs: “A Cornell analysis identifies four threats that endanger democracy – political polarization; conflict over who belongs as a full member of the political community; rising economic inequality; and the concentration of power in the nation's top leader — that have converged for the first time in American history. 2. Rise…”
- Declining Trust in Facts and Institutions Imposes Costs on Society
Backs: “racially or ethnically motivated or anti-government/anti-authority violent extremism. 3. Erosion of Trust and Truth Decay. Rand Corporation defines the current discourse as "Truth Decay," defined as increasing disagreement about facts, a blurring of the line between opinion and fact, an increase in the relative volume…”